Self-awareness

The Problem With Being the Person Who Always Has the Answer

Image created with AI using ChatGPT

In many organizations, the people who advance into leadership positions are those who have consistently demonstrated an ability to solve problems, make decisions, and provide answers when others are uncertain. Their expertise earns them credibility, and their willingness to step in often becomes one of the qualities for which they are most valued.

But as their responsibilities evolve, the very behaviors that contributed to their success can begin to limit the development of those around them.

I frequently work with leaders who are exceptionally capable, deeply invested in their teams, and genuinely committed to helping others succeed. Yet when someone approaches them with a challenge, their instinct is to offer a solution. They see the problem, recognize a path forward, and provide direction, often before the other person has had an opportunity to fully consider the situation themselves.

In the moment, this approach feels efficient. The problem gets resolved, the employee receives guidance, and everyone moves forward. What is less immediately apparent is the pattern that can develop over time.

When a leader consistently provides the answers, employees may become increasingly reliant on that leader's judgment rather than developing confidence in their own. Questions that could have been resolved independently are escalated, decisions are deferred, and the leader becomes an unnecessary point of dependency within the organization.

Ironically, the same leader may eventually express frustration that their team lacks initiative or struggles to make decisions without them.

The challenge is that developing others requires a different kind of contribution. Rather than demonstrating expertise at every opportunity, effective leaders must become intentional about creating opportunities for others to exercise their own judgment.

This does not mean withholding guidance or allowing employees to struggle unnecessarily. There are certainly situations where experience, urgency, or risk warrants a direct answer. The distinction lies in recognizing when immediate intervention is necessary and when a conversation could serve a more valuable developmental purpose.

Something as simple as asking, "How have you thought about approaching this?" or "What would you recommend?" can shift the responsibility for problem-solving back to the individual. From there, a leader can offer perspective, challenge assumptions, and help refine the proposed approach without taking ownership of the decision entirely.

Over time, these interactions do more than resolve individual challenges. They build confidence, strengthen critical thinking, and establish an expectation that employees should arrive prepared to contribute their own perspective.

For leaders accustomed to being the person everyone turns to, this adjustment can be uncomfortable. It requires patience, a willingness to tolerate approaches that differ from their own, and an understanding that developing capability sometimes takes longer than simply providing the answer.

But leadership effectiveness cannot be measured solely by how many problems a leader can solve personally. It must also be reflected in the organization's ability to function, make sound decisions, and continue progressing without that leader's constant involvement.

Perhaps one of the more important transitions in leadership is recognizing that your value is no longer defined primarily by the answers you provide, but by the judgment and capability you develop in others.

When Feedback Feels Personal: Staying Curious Long Enough to Learn

Feedback is relatively easy to receive when we agree with it. The harder—and often more useful—work begins when someone offers an observation that feels inaccurate, unfair, or inconsistent with how we understand ourselves.

Smiley face, neutral face, frown face

Illustration created with AI

Our natural response in those moments is often to evaluate the feedback before we have really considered it. We explain the context, identify what the other person may not understand, or begin building the case for why their assessment isn’t quite right. Sometimes, of course, it isn’t. Feedback is inherently subjective, and not every observation deserves the same weight.

But feedback does not have to be entirely accurate to contain useful information.

I often encourage leaders to separate intent from impact when they are trying to make sense of difficult feedback. We tend to evaluate our own behavior with the benefit of knowing our intentions, while everyone around us experiences that behavior primarily through its impact. A leader may know that she is thoughtful and collaborative, for example, while others experience her reluctance to speak early in a meeting as a lack of confidence. Another may believe he is being direct and decisive while his team experiences the same behavior as dismissive.

The question, then, is not simply, “Is this feedback true?” A more productive question is, “What might someone be experiencing that caused them to reach this conclusion?”

That subtle shift matters because it replaces defensiveness with curiosity without requiring us to accept every piece of feedback as fact. Ask for examples. Look for patterns rather than isolated comments. Consider whether the perception changes depending on the audience or environment. Most importantly, resist the urge to explain your intention before you fully understand the impact.

This is particularly important as leaders become more senior. Leadership is not only about what we intend to communicate; it is also about our ability to recognize how our behavior is being interpreted by the people around us. Perception should not dictate every decision, but neither can it simply be dismissed because it does not match our own assessment.

The goal of feedback is not to construct a perfectly accurate description of who you are. It is to give you information about how your leadership is being experienced.

You can disagree with some of that information and still learn from it. In fact, sometimes the feedback we are most inclined to reject is precisely the feedback worth examining a little longer.

It's Not All About You

A pair of glasses

Picture this. You recently promoted a team member for their hard work. Outside of seniority, your recently promoted member, let’s call this person Sal, has worked hard to accomplish a great quantity of projects. Recently, one of Sal’s direct reports put in their notice. The report has had trouble for over a year, struggling with personal challenges, something you’ve been very understanding about. 

In your effort to be innovative, you dream up a solution: By offering Sal’s subordinate flexibility to continue to work, albeit not full-time, you allow space for a person who is personally struggling. Your team is performing well and you’ve invested significant time into your team’s camaraderie. 

We often wish organizations would be creative about the “human element.” People are complicated: there must be some allowances. Typically these allowances are measured in policy to ensure folks don’t take advantage. I’m all for standards and policies, but I’m also a strong advocate for innovation. If a company can retain a team member, even if the role and scope look a little different than what they were doing previously, that’s a win for everyone. 

While I could focus on the monumental win here of problem-solving when dealing with personnel issues, I actually want to go back to Sal. 

Sal’s response to this solution was dismal, at best. When approached with the idea to offer this arrangement to the team member, you are met with disbelief. “What will other people think?” “I had a hard year too.” The general tone is negative. 

You decide to proceed, as you feel it reflects the values of the team as a whole, but are troubled by Sal’s self-focused response. What do you do? 

It’s apparent there’s an empathy gap. Everyone has their own “stuff.” And only we know what we go through. But when anyone is put into a managerial position, the truth is empathy must increase. You must try to put on their glasses and see the world through a different lens.  If Sal’s boss also looked at Sal and any direct report without empathy, there’s no way the aforementioned solution would have been dreamt up. So how can we increase empathy, one of the most important attributes for a leader? Stay tuned, as I’ll provide suggestions for you and your team in my next post.

Listening Learnings

In my last post, I spoke about listening when you can’t hear. A true challenge that can end in people filling the void with their voice because it’s the only voice they hear well. But in the circumstance when you can hear well in general, are you being intentional about listening? 

In my coaching series, a focus area is that of listening. With each person who works with me, we dive into not only the types of listening (discriminative, comprehensive, critical, etc.), but the essentiality of the skill. Listening is indeed a skill, and it is one we do not often hone. Because of our broad ability to hear as a sense, we confuse this gift with being thoughtful about listening well. 

Walk down this path with me. Think of a person in your life who is a terrible listener. Perhaps he or she interjects, finishes your sentences, gazes into space, takes a phone call, responds to text messages, and has side-bar conversations. How does that person make you feel? Nine out of 10 times, the responses to this question are similar. When not listened to, people feel rejected, dismissed, unimportant, an inconvenience, insecure, or frustrated. But wait, what’s the flip? Think of a person in your life who is a strong listener. Someone who paraphrases your words, demonstrates through body language they are engaged, and maintains eye contact. How does this person make you feel? Again, sentiments are shared: the person who is listened to feels validated, heard, and at ease. (Is it any wonder we have an anxious generation??) 

Now that we’ve identified just some of the emotional value in listening to others, what else can it accomplish? Listening well can minimize miscommunication, establish trust, and even save time.

Just today, I can think of several examples I experienced and witnessed of others not listening well (or at all). While the act of listening can certainly improve interpersonal communication, it really is a tool to lean into when it comes to being a people manager. Setting a tone that your staff is worthy of being listened to is instrumental to your managerial skills.

Are you pretty confident you are a good listener? I guarantee you there is work to be done and I’ll be glad to help.